Skip to Main Content
FlightPushFLIGHTPUSH
NTSB Safety Recommendations

Learn

Dashboard My Courses Mastery Map Practice Flight Bag

Resources

CFR & AIM FAA Orders Handbooks & Guides Certification Standards Pilot/Controller Glossary Advisory Circulars Legal Interpretations
Safety Center
Articles Trust Center
Help Center FAQ Status
  1. Safety Center
  2. NTSB Safety Recommendations
  3. NTSB A-72-122
Loading
flightpush.co home

NTSB · Safety Recommendation

Safety Recommendation A-72-122

Recommendation

TO ALL U.S. AIR CARRIERS: Instruct maintenance crews to check for deactivation of the CVR before restoring electrical power to an aircraft after any unusual occurrence.

Safety Issue and Context

OVER THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS, THERE HAVE BEEN A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF INSTANCES IN WHICH, SUBSEQUENT TO A LANDING AFTER A REPORTABLE OCCURRENCE OR AN INCIDENT, THE FLIGHTCREW HAS FAILED TO HALT THE OPERATION OF THE COCKPIT VOICE RECORDER (CVR), THUS CAUSING THE ERASURE OF ALL RECORDING PERTINENT TO THE OCCURRENCE. MUCH SIGNIFICANT INFORMATION WITH VALUABLE ACCIDENT-PREVENTION POTENTIAL HAS BEEN LOST.

Response History

November 8, 1972 · NTSB Correspondence · American Airlines, Inc.

-From M.W. Eastburn, Director- Safety, American Airlines: This is in response to Safety Recommendations A-72-119 through 122 issued August 24, 1972. We wish to inform you that each of the recommendations have been reviewed and action taken to insure that they have been incorporated in the appropriate Maintenance, Flight Equipment Operating Manuals and in each of our recurrent annual training programs. All of the Safety Recommendations issued by the Board are thoroughly reviewed within American Airlines and we have found them to be of great value and benefit in the review and improvement of our operation.

October 30, 1972 · NTSB Correspondence · Eastern Airlines, Inc.

Thank you very much for your recent letter in which you supported the National Transportation Safety Board's recommendations as to methods to help ensure deactivation and task priorities of a more pressing nature than deacticating the CVR. As you know, our primary concern at this time is the infrequent case where the CVT is inadvertently allowed to operator or bulk erated subsequent to an incident of Board interest. We believe that the establishment of approved operating an training procedures covered by checklists would go far toward ensuring compliance with the intent of 121.359(e) which currently imposes the burden of record retention on the air carrier.

However, we are concerned, as we indicated to the Federal Aviation Administation in our letter of August 24, 1972, that 121.359 should be ammended to state that the pilot-in-command would take all reasonable actions to assure that the CVR record would be available for study by our investigators after a reportable incident. We would not antipicate tha the FASA would even initiate enforcement action in those instances where it was evident that the pilot was acting to preserve his own life or the lives of others and failed to preserve a CVR record. We appreciate your comments and willingness to work to improve aviation safety.

Read Recommendation

Recommendation Facts

Status
Closed - Acceptable Action
Issued
August 24, 1972
Priority
CLASS II
Recipient
Midwest Airlines, Inc., Mercer Enterprise, Intermountain Aviation, Inc., Flying W Airways, Inc., Air Mid East, Inc., Overseas National Airways, Inc., Saturn Airways, Inc., Modern Air Transport, Inc., McCulloch International Airlines, Capitol International Airways, Wien Consolidated Airways, Inc., Western Airlines, Inc., United Airlines, Inc., Trans World Airlines, Inc., Johnson Flying Service, Inc., Southwest Airlines, Pacific Southwest Airlines, Inc., Air California, World Airways, Inc., Universal Airlines, Inc., Trans International Airlines, Aero-Spacelines, Inc., Southeast Airlines, Inc., Ortner Air Service, Inc., Interior Airways, Inc., Holiday Airlines, Inc., Fairways Corporation, Air America, Inc., Perdue Airlines, Inc., Texas International Airlines, Inc., Southern Airways, Inc., Southern Air Transport, Inc., Seaboard World Airlines, Inc., Reeve Aleutian Airways, Inc., Piedmont Airlines, Pan American World Airways, Inc., Ozark Air Lines, Inc., Northwest Airlines, Inc., Northeast Airlines, Inc., North Central Airlines, Inc., National Airlines, Inc., Hughes Air West, Hawaiian Airlines, Inc., Frontier Airlines, Inc., Eastern Airlines, Inc., Delta Airlines, Inc., Continental Airlines, Inc., Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc., Braniff, Inc., Aloha Airlines, Inc., Allegheny Airlines, Inc., Alaska Airlines, Inc., Airlift International, Inc., American Airlines, Inc.
Adopted
July 26, 1972
Closed
January 1, 1975
Related Investigation
80555
Related Report
None

Recipient Responses

Midwest Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Mercer Enterprise: Closed - Acceptable Action

Intermountain Aviation, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Flying W Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Air Mid East, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Overseas National Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Saturn Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Modern Air Transport, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

McCulloch International Airlines: Closed - Acceptable Action

Capitol International Airways: Closed - Acceptable Action

Wien Consolidated Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Western Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

United Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Trans World Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Johnson Flying Service, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Southwest Airlines: Closed - Acceptable Action

Pacific Southwest Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Air California: Closed - Acceptable Action

World Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Universal Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Trans International Airlines: Closed - Acceptable Action

Aero-Spacelines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Southeast Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Ortner Air Service, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Interior Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Holiday Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Fairways Corporation: Closed - Acceptable Action

Air America, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Perdue Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Texas International Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Southern Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Southern Air Transport, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Seaboard World Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Reeve Aleutian Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Piedmont Airlines: Closed - Acceptable Action

Pan American World Airways, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Ozark Air Lines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Northwest Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Northeast Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

North Central Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

National Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Hughes Air West: Closed - Acceptable Action

Hawaiian Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Frontier Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Eastern Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Delta Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Continental Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Braniff, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Aloha Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Allegheny Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Alaska Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

Airlift International, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action

American Airlines, Inc.: Closed - Acceptable Action